Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag®

The Elegant Farmer’s Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag® is Simply the Best. Stuffed with mounds of perfectly steamed, incredibly juicy Ida Red apples, the crust positively bulges with goodness. Being baked in a paper bag makes our sugar-cookie like top crust uniquely crunchy while keeping the traditional bottom crust amazingly light and flaky. Our signature sugar cookie-like top crust and hearty sweet-tart apples combine to make for simply the best pie ever! Named “America’s Best Pie” by the Food Network, Wall Street Journal, Gourmet Magazine, Milwaukee Magazine and four generations of fans. Enjoy!

Simply the Best

Farm Kitchen Bakery Pies & Crisps

Available in the Market Year Round

Our Simply the Best Pies & Crisps are made fresh daily in our Farm Kitchen Bakery.  Our Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag® is available year round along with our delicious Caramel Apple, Blueberry Apple, Peachy Apple, Rhubarb Apple Pies and our Apple and Cherry Crisps Baked in a Paper Bag.

Apple Pie 

9″ Pie $24.99

8″ Pie $21.99

5″ Pie $9.99

Caramel Apple Pie 

8″ Pie $24.99

5″ Pie $9.99

Blueberry Apple 

8″ Pie $24.99 

5″ Pie $9.99

Peachy Apple Pie

8″ Pie $24.99

5″ Pie $9.99

Rhubarb Apple Pie

8″ Pie $24.99

5″ Pie $9.99

Apple Crisp

8″ Crisp $17.99

5″ Crisp $7.99

Cherry Crisp

8″ Crisp $19.99

5″ Crisp $8.99

Shipping Pies & Crisps

The Elegant Farmer no longer ships its pies or crisps.  If you would like to have an Elegant Farmer pie or crisp shipped to you please visit the gourmet online food shipping website Goldbelly. Please note that Goldbelly sets its own prices for its online products and shipping.  Any questions about shipping pies or crisps or issues with your pie or crisp online Goldbelly order, please contact Goldbelly customer service department they are happy to help.

Simply the Best Farm Kitchen Bakery

In Market Seasonal Pies & Crisps

These Simply the Best pies are available seasonally in the market throughout the year.  Strawberry Rhubarb, Summerberry, Berried Treasure & Pineapple and Fall/Winter: Cranberry Apple & Pumpkin. Please call the market for availability and pricing at 262-363-6770.

Strawberry Rhubarb


Berried Treasure


Cranberry Apple

Pumpkin Pie

Cranberry Walnut

Freezer Section Only